- New York Attorney General Letitia James and Governor Kathy Hochul have announced a lawsuit against Polymarket US.
- The state alleges the prediction platform is operating illegal, unlicensed gambling in New York.
- The lawsuit seeks to stop the activity and asks for fines, forfeiture of alleged illegal gains and restitution for users.
**ID:** N25-03
**Site:** NewsBTC
**Status:** READY
**Author:** NewsBTC Editorial Team
**Focus Keyword:** Polymarket
**Image Keyword:** Regulation
**Category:** Regulation
**Tags:** Polymarket, New York, Prediction Markets, Regulation, Kalshi
**Primary Source:** https://ag.ny.gov/press-release
New York Says The Federal Structure Does Not Override State Gambling Law
Polymarket returned to the U.S. market after acquiring regulated exchange infrastructure and operating under the federal commodities framework.
New York is arguing that this does not give the platform a free pass under state gambling rules.
According to the Attorney General’s office, an investigation found that Polymarket offered users the ability to wager on sporting events without a New York gambling license.
The state also alleges the platform exposes users below New York’s legal gambling age of 21 to those markets.
The lawsuit asks a court to block Polymarket from continuing to operate what the state describes as an unlicensed gambling business.
It also seeks financial penalties, forfeiture of alleged illegal proceeds and restitution.
Prediction Markets Are Running Into A Jurisdiction Problem
The dispute highlights a structural problem that has followed prediction markets as they expand.
At the federal level, event contracts can fall under the Commodity Futures Trading Commission.
At the state level, regulators can look at exactly the same product and see a wager.
Sports contracts make that conflict particularly sharp.
A market on inflation or an election may be framed as a forecasting or hedging instrument.
A contract paying out on the result of a basketball game can look much closer to conventional sports betting.
The New York lawsuit does not establish that Polymarket has broken the law; those allegations now have to be tested in court.
But it raises the stakes considerably.
Prediction markets have grown from a crypto curiosity into a substantial consumer product.
As that happens, the industry’s biggest challenge may not be finding users.
It may be convincing federal and state regulators that everyone agrees on what these markets actually are.
*This article was written by the News Desk and edited by [Samuel Rae](https://www.newsbtc.com/author/rae-samuel/).*
