Back by popular demand, here are a few thoughts on some current topics in sports.
1. I think the new CFL rules are fine, but the new playoff format is awful.
When the Edmonton Elks defeated the Montreal Alouettes in the 113th Grey Cup game on Sunday, it marked the end of an era of sorts for the CFL.
Starting next year, the most impactful and controversial of the rules changes ushered in by second-year commissioner Stewart Johnston will take effect. The length of the field will be reduced from 110 yards to 100, the endzones chopped from 20 yards to 15, and the goalposts pushed back from the goal line to the back of the endzone. These follow some smaller changes introduced this year to improve game flow and stop teams from booting the ball through the back of the endzone for a single point.
Johnston has said the goal is “trading field goals for touchdowns” and insisted the changes are “necessary” to “win in the attention economy” in a time where general interest in the CFL has declined and the league wanted to make itself more attractive to casual fans, TV partners and advertisers.
Edmonton Elks win 113th Grey Cup, defeating Montreal Alouettes
He may be right. But the former TSN president’s reforms have upset a lot of diehard CFL fans. Many of them believe Johnston is Americanizing their beloved league by removing signature features like the 55-yard line and the extra-long endzone, thus making it too much like the NFL.
Back in the summer, I received a thoughtful email from a fan in B.C. who described herself as a lifelong CFL fan and said she was part of a group from around the country who were pushing back on the changes. They felt that Johnston and the team owners “don’t care about the current fans” and were “not sure exactly who they are trying to chase to become fans with the changes.” She added that “in this time of threatened annexation by the United States, we’re shocked the CFL chose this moment to enact these changes which erase much of the identity of the superior Canadian game and meld it to a form uncomfortably close to the NFL.”
I definitely feel for these fans. They make some valid points, and the risk of alienating these loyal customers is something the CFL should take seriously.
Fajardo’s 4 scores lead Elks past Alouettes to capture 113th Grey Cup
Austin Mack lobbies Cody Fajardo to stay and build a ‘dynasty’ after Elks’ Grey Cup win
At the same time, as someone who admittedly spends much more time watching the NFL, I have to say I don’t mind the changes. The longer field and endzones don’t do much for me, and I’ll be glad to see the goalposts out of the way (their current positioning always struck me as bothersome and, frankly, a bit goofy). Meanwhile, it seems to me that the league is keeping the core elements that make the CFL the CFL — namely, three downs, a wider field, the Canadian player quota and the “waggle,” where multiple offensive backfield players can be in motion before the snap, including toward the line of scrimmage.
However, one change I can’t stomach is the new playoff format.
Until now, six of the CFL’s nine teams made the playoffs. Starting next year, an absurd eight teams will qualify. The revamped first round even features a pair of non-elimination games as the top two seeds in each division square off for a bye to the Grey Cup semifinals, with the losers of those games staying alive — and possibly coming back to re-play those matchups a couple of weeks later.
What you missed at this year’s Grey Cup
The goal of this post-season expansion is pretty clear: create more inventory for playoff-hungry broadcasters and advertisers, who get their biggest audiences during the post-season. It’s already paid off, as a new rights deal with Bell Media (TSN’s parent company), the streaming service DAZN and YouTube will pay the CFL a reported $83M per season — up from $50M under the just-expired contract.
I guess you have to hand it to Johnston here. His mandate was to make more money for the league, and he’s done that. But what about the hardcore fans? They get a devalued regular season, a bloated playoffs where not all the games matter as much, and a bunch of new rules that many of them didn’t ask for. We’ll see how that goes over.
2. I think I’m worried the U.S. is taking over hockey.
On Monday, the United States dominated Canada 6-2 in the final of the women’s hockey world championship in Denmark, winning the title for the second straight year. This American team also defeated Canada in the Olympic gold-medal game last winter, so they’ve now won or successfully defended what we might call the women’s hockey championship belt three straight times.
The U.S. also beat Canada in the men’s Olympic final, giving them three of the four top “best on best” titles at the moment. The exception is the men’s world juniors, which Sweden won last year in Minnesota while Canada took the bronze and the host U.S. shockingly lost in the quarterfinals to Finland.
Captain Hilary Knight guides Americans to a 2nd-straight women’s world championship title
Historically, Canada is still the No. 1 hockey nation. Despite its best players not participating for decades, no other country has won more Olympic men’s gold medals. Canada also leads the U.S. in Olympic women’s golds 5-3 and has a 13-12 edge over the Americans in women’s world championships (no other country has captured one of either). At the world juniors, Canada’s 20 titles put it way ahead of Russia (13 if you include the Soviet Union and the post-Soviet Commonwealth of Independent States) and the third-place U.S. (seven).
But I’m concerned that our grip on the global hockey throne is slipping away — especially in the women’s game, where the Americans have blown open a once razor’s-edge rivalry. They’ve now won 10 of their last 11 games against Canada while often looking like the much younger, faster and stronger team.
U.S. captures third women’s world hockey title in 4 years, downing rival Canadians
On the men’s side, you could argue that the Americans stole their first Olympic gold medal since the 1980 Miracle on Ice thanks to a lucky combination of incredible saves by Connor Hellebuyck, an unconscionable open-net miss by Nathan MacKinnon and an unserious 3-on-3 overtime format. But, going back to the 4 Nations Face-Off in 2025, the U.S. and Canadian teams have looked pretty evenly matched. Meanwhile, Canada has failed to reach the final at three straight world juniors — a span in which the U.S. has won two golds.
And then there’s the demographic changes. Though Canada still produces more NHL players than any other country, that share has dropped from a majority just a decade ago to about 43 per cent this season, according to QuantHockey. Meanwhile, the U.S. has climbed from around 15 per cent at the turn of the century to 27 per cent this season. And while Canada still boasts the best player in the world in Connor McDavid, only three of the current top 10 scorers are Canadian — the same amount as the States.
Several factors have fuelled the rise of U.S. hockey, including the growth of NCAA programs, the formation of the National Team Development Program for the top American teenagers, and NHL commissioner Gary Bettman’s (mostly) successful sunbelt expansion. But the bottom line is that the sport seems more popular than ever throughout the States, from the grassroots level up to NHL arenas. And, considering the U.S. has about eight times the population of Canada and is on the whole a much richer country, the resources are in place to take this even further.
3. I think Alex Ovechkin might be washed.
The first two takes ran pretty long (a common occurrence at this newsletter) so I’ll keep this one short.
Alex Ovechkin has scored only one goal through 18 games this season, putting him on pace to finish his final NHL season with five goals after averaging 44 over his first 21 NHL campaigns. The all-time regular-season goals king is also in jeopardy of falling short of Wayne Gretzky’s record for most career goals including the playoffs, which seemed destined to belong to Ovechkin before he retires. The big Russian has been stuck at 1,007 for more than a month, leaving him nine behind the Great One.
Ovechkin has been known to bounce back with a vengeance from slow starts. And his shooting percentage this season is an unsustainably low 3.1 — almost 10 points below his lifetime mark. But, at age 41, he has also mustered only four assists while averaging just 13:37 of ice time (down nearly four minutes from last season) as the end of his incredibly productive career draws near.










