Alberta’s premier says her government might invoke the notwithstanding clause to defend laws affecting transgender people because courts may take “years and years and years” to resolve the issue, and she wants to “protect kids.”
Smith, who made the comments Saturday on her provincewide radio call-in program, was responding to news that an internal memo from her government says it plans to apply the clause this fall to its three laws that police school pronouns, female sports and gender-affirming health care.
The government’s memo says it plans is to bring the notwithstanding clause proposal to cabinet Oct. 21.
“I’m prepared to go to court and battle it out. I think we need to. But if it turns out that the court process may take years and years and years to resolve, then we may have to take that measure in order to protect kids,” Smith said, noting government lawyers are looking into it and a decision hasn’t yet been made.
“Puberty blockers, by definition, stop the process of sexual maturity and it means that you’re sterilizing children, and we’re not going to do it.”
Alberta looks to use notwithstanding clause on 3 transgender laws
The government passed a law late last year, but not fully in effect, which bans doctors from providing treatment such as puberty blockers and hormone therapy to those under 16.
2SLGBTQ+ advocacy groups Egale and Skipping Stone, along with five gender-diverse youth and their families, have launched a legal challenge against the law and it is currently subject to a temporary court-ordered injunction. Alberta is appealing, arguing the injunction was premature.
Puberty blockers are given by injection to youth experiencing gender dysphoria, where a person’s gender identity does not match the sex they were assigned at birth. The medications block physical changes such as breast development due to estrogen or a deepening voice from testosterone, and allow youth time to decide if they want to continue gender-affirming surgeries.
According to the Mayo Clinic website, the medicine most often used for blocking puberty, gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues, don’t cause permanent physical changes. The site says when a person stops taking GnRH analogues, puberty starts again.
When granting the temporary injunction in June, Justice Allison Kuntz wrote that denying treatment risks causing youth emotional harm and exposing them to permanent physical changes that don’t match their gender identity.
The notwithstanding clause allows governments to override certain sections of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms for up to five years. Smith has long downplayed a need to use it, although last December she said it could be used as a last resort to shield the health restrictions law.
She appeared to dismiss the importance of the government memo when speaking about it on the radio Saturday.
“First of all, it’s a leaked memo, so obviously somebody’s upset about it, and so they’re trying to make a media story out of it,” she said, stressing children shouldn’t be making such health decisions.
“If we don’t think a 10-year-old can decide to sign a contract, to smoke, to join the army, to do drugs, to be truant from school, then they can’t decide whether or not they want to have babies as an adult.”
The Canadian Medical Association and three Alberta-based doctors are also challenging the health law in a separate case launched in May. They argue the law violates a doctor’s right to freedom of conscience.
