The Transportation Safety Board of Canada (TSB) says a train derailment in northwestern Ontario last year highlights safety risks of wheels built before 2003, when manufacturing standards were updated.
On Feb. 4, 2025, a Canadian National Railway freight train was travelling west from Fort Frances to Winnipeg when 14 loaded hopper cars carrying fertilizer derailed near Emo.
No dangerous goods were involved and no injuries were reported, the TSB said.
The independent agency — which investigates air, marine, pipeline and rail transportation occurrences — on Tuesday released the results of its investigation. It determined that the derailment was caused by imperfections in a railcar wheel, resulting in a shattered rim failure.
The failed wheel was manufactured in 1992, the report says.
“This is not an isolated case,” the TSB said in a news release. “Between 2003 and 2025, the TSB investigated 14 other derailments due to broken rims, eight of which involved failures in wheels manufactured before the implementation of the AAR (Association of American Railroads) steel cleanliness standard,” including a recently published TSB report on the 2023 derailment near Uncas, Alta.
An image shows the missing portion of the freight train wheel tread from the Feb. 4, 2025 incident near Emo, Ont. (Transportation Safety Board of Canada)
“The number of pre-2003 wheels still in service is unknown, and there is currently no proactive retirement strategy for these wheels. Therefore, the board remains concerned that maintaining these wheels in service leaves a residual risk of sudden in-service wheel-rim failure and derailment.”
In response to the incident, Transport Canada issued a letter to CN on Feb. 28, 2025, for non-compliance with Sections 4.2 and 4.5 of the Railway Freight Car Inspection and Safety Rules due to “lack of proper documentation confirming that the freight car inspection took place before the train entered Canada at Fort Frances,” the TSB report says.
2 hospitalized after CN Rail train derails into Skeena River near Terrace, B.C.
TSB investigates Alberta train derailment involving dangerous goods, but no reported leaks or fires
CBC News reached out to CN for comment on the report’s findings and concerns with older wheels.
In an emailed statement on Wednesday, CN acknowledged receiving the TSB report.
“We thank the TSB for its work, and are continuing to review and validate the report’s findings,” wrote Ashley Michnowski, a spokesperson for the railway.
“Safety is a core value at CN, and we remain committed to protecting our employees, customers, and the communities through which we operate.”
Ian Naish is a rail safety consultant based in Ottawa and former director of rail investigations for TSB.
He said Tuesday’s report emphasizes the importance of analyzing recorded wheel impact loads so that defective wheels can be removed from service.
Ian Naish is a rail safety consultant based in Ottawa and a former Transporation Safety Board of Canada director of rail investigations. (Jean Delisle/CBC)
“You don’t know the exact number that are going to be problem wheels every year, but there’s millions of dollars you can save by doing that,” Naish said.
“Technology’s improved in terms of statistical analysis and firm datasets.”
The TSB report stresses the importance of mitigating these risks in the future.
Two fragments of wheel tread found near where the freight train derailed near Emo. (Transportation Safety Board of Canada)
Wheels manufactured before the 2003 AAR steel cleanliness standards were introduced “may contain internal material imperfections that leave them more vulnerable to wheel-rim failures,” the report says, adding that’s why “the absence of a mitigation strategy increases the likelihood that such wheels will fail in service.”
“If technologies that identify emerging wheel defects are not leveraged, opportunities to detect these defects may be missed, resulting in an increased risk of in-service failure.”
Shattered rims and broken wheels cost Canadian railways about $50 million a year, added Naish.
Repentigny calls for stop to rail traffic after TSB investigation reveals ‘several deficiencies’
Railway operations slowly resume in Repentigny, Que., following major derailment
“It sounds like it’s one of the most frequent reasons for derailments, and I think the most expensive cost,” Naish said. “If you get a broken wheel derailment, the pileups worsen, the damage is worse, generally speaking.”
He hopes CN and Transport Canada take the report seriously.
“It looks like an opportunity to improve safety and save money. Maybe something positive will come out of all of this.”









