The Prince Edward Island government has found the person it wants to lead an independent review into how police handled the Byron Carr murder investigation, and that will be retired Nova Scotia justice Duncan Beveridge.
Attorney General and Justice Minister Bloyce Thompson made the announcement Wednesday in the P.E.I. Legislature. He said Beveridge’s extensive experience and background make him the “ideal” person to review the Carr case.
Beveridge served on the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal and is a former Crown prosecutor, defence attorney and past-president of the Nova Scotia Criminal Lawyers Association.
He was also involved in the Westray prosecution, an investigation into the Nova Scotia Public Prosecution Service after its decision not to prosecute the operators of Westray mine in the aftermath of an explosion that killed 26 miners.
Duncan Beveridge served as a justice on the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal and is a former Crown prosecutor, defence attorney and past-president of the Nova Scotia Criminal Lawyers Association. (Nova Scotia Courts)
In the review of the Carr investigation, Beveridge will look into Charlottetown Police Services and how it conducted itself and handled evidence during the investigation into the decades-old murder.
Carr was found dead in his Charlottetown home on Nov. 12, 1988. The 36-year-old teacher had been strangled with a towel and stabbed with a kitchen knife.
The case went cold until 2024, when police arrested Todd Joseph Irving, who was charged with first-degree murder and interfering with human remains.
But last month, all charges in the case were withdrawn after it came to light that crucial evidence — including a knife found at the scene and the towel used to strangle Carr — had been lost. The province ordered the independent review of the investigation the following week.
CBC P.E.I.’s full coverage of the Byron Carr case can be found here
Thompson said Carr’s family deserves answers, and he hopes this review provides those.
“My heart goes out to the family,” he said.
“This family needs some sort of closure on this murder case. I feel for the family, and I feel for the community. Charlottetown was definitely impacted by this murder, and we still don’t have those answers, so let’s hope this brings just a little bit of closure.”
The review will be done under the province’s Police Act, so it will not be a public inquiry.
Thompson said the review will begin Jan. 4 and is expected to take anywhere from several months to a year.
Liberal MLA Carolyn Simpson said she’s “quite pleased” to hear Beveridge is handling the review, considering his depth of experience.
Green Leader Matt MacFarlane agreed, calling Beveridge a “fine choice” to do the work.
“Justice Beveridge is certainly well-known throughout the region,” MacFarlane said in the legislature Wednesday.
“Justice delayed is justice denied. This was a case where justice was denied for Byron Carr, so let’s hope we can learn from this.”









